Thank you for submitting a review!
Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!
Highly recommended Gould’s playing. The sound.
Magic performance, but the sound is dull. Listening to the same performance on one of the YouTube versions I hear tiny background sounds and sparkle that are missing from this version. I am purchasing the Sony CD of Gould & Bernstein Concertos 1 - 4, hoping the sound is better. The HDTT online store and download worked well for me.
Even if Bernstein had publicly a notorious disagreement with Glenn Gould ("Who is the boss!?) they were two of a kind. Here is evident a sublime compenetration between two neurotic personalities, each one in his own style. Thankfully, these two almost mad idiosincratic individuals find here a point of synergy, making of this performance of the Beethoven's Fourth Piano Concerto a milestone in the historic of a plethora of disc dedicated to It. Thankfully, too, the transfer to digital respects all the sonic characteristics of the original tapes, including Gould's self-vocals we "Gould's e" listeners love so much. A must.
On of the best performance of the Concerto No. 4
If you have forgotten, or never knew, what lyrical piano playing Glenn Gould was capable of, get this superb transfer from HDTT and be overwhelmed by the way it restores the naturalness and immediacy of Gould’s wholly unique artistry and opens up the space around the orchestra. Charles Rosen called the opening “at once poetically resonant and reticent”: as few others Gould knew the secret of that and goes on to create pure magic with it again later when he arrives at the recapitulation (10:59). Playing throughout is poetic and powerful at the same time, textures are crystal clear but warm, driven by Gould’s unflagging imagination, and his way of bringing out the left hand a pure delight (e.g., 6:17 and again 13:37!). Strangely enough, the prosaic one here is Bernstein. Listen for example to Gould’s sublime transition at 09:45 as he trims his double forte down to pianissimo over the 2-bar trills and slides effortlessly into Gouldian lyrical mode: celli and basses steal in beautifully pizzicato with the main 4-note motif but four bars later Bernstein already sounds, well, “prosaic.” Gould’s Andante con moto is no “Orpheus in Hades”, but for the way he refuses to stick to piano, sounds almost defiant. Of course HDTT makes all the difference for the strong natural base line we’re getting here, both from piano and orchestra, with Bernstein fully in harmony with his soloist this time and responding, after all, with a rich and diversified orchestral palette, especially in the tuttis. By the end of the Rondo you’ll be pressing the repeat button.